Design Problems Drive 40.5% of Construction Disputes

Contractors and owners should tighten design completion and scope control, since these drove the largest share of disputes across 122 countries.

Updated on Nov. 2, 2026 in Construction

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a single unfinished concrete column with exposed rebar on a slab, in deep red and cream, evoking structural design disputes.
HKA's ninth annual CRUX report, released November 2, found design problems contributed to 40.5% of construction disputes across 2,410 projects in 122 countries. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

HKA published its ninth annual CRUX Insight report on November 2, 2026, analyzing 2,410 construction projects across 122 countries with combined investment of US$2.56 trillion. Design-related problems contributed to disputes on 40.5% of the projects, and the cumulative value of sums in dispute reached US$100 billion.

Why it matters

The findings point to design quality and scope control, not just site execution, as the main sources of cost and schedule claims, which bears on how contractors price bids, manage design handoffs, and document change orders. HKA attributed part of the problem to political pressure to start nuclear construction before planning and design work was complete.

The sample covers 2,410 projects in 122 countries with US$2.56 trillion in combined investment, and changes in project scope affected 33.4% of them. Improved outcomes were reported for projects scheduled to complete from 2020 onward, though the report's sample is limited to projects that involved claims or disputes.

The players

HKA

HKA is a global construction and engineering consultancy that investigates claims and disputes on large projects for owners and contractors.

The details

Each project in the sample was a claim or dispute that HKA consultants investigated, so the percentages describe where disputes arise rather than the rate at which all projects go wrong. Design errors, late design information and incomplete designs each contributed to a meaningful share of disputes, and when design is not settled before work starts, contractors and owners tend to price uncertainty into claims. Scope changes affected a third of projects, which means change-order administration and documentation carry direct financial weight. The report's cost measures are amounts claimed or in dispute, which can diverge from what is ultimately paid.

Timeline

  1. November 2, 2026: HKA published its ninth annual CRUX Insight report.

  2. 2020 onward: Projects scheduled to complete from this year showed improved outcomes.

Market Landscape

The CRUX series has run annually for nine editions, giving the industry a long-running dataset on how disputes trace back to design and scope. This year's edition adds fresh data on nuclear projects, where disputed sums averaged 122% of contract budgets.

Contractors and owners should tighten design completion before mobilization and document scope changes as they occur, since design-related problems drove the largest share of disputes. Firms pricing nuclear or other large public works should weigh the report's finding that disputed sums can exceed contract budgets.

The takeaway

Treat completed design and documented scope as financial controls rather than administrative tasks, because they determine how much of a project's risk becomes a claim. Review your change-order and design-handoff procedures against the CRUX findings before your next bid.

Further reading

For broader context on how these disputes unfold, explore the Construction section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Construction Briefing.