Design Firms' Claim Costs Climb as Frequency Holds

Architects and engineers should budget for higher per-claim defense and settlement costs even where claim counts are flat.

Updated on Nov. 5, 2026 in Construction

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a steel I-beam resting on concrete blocks, with one cracked section exposing its inner structure.
Average claim costs for U.S. architect and engineer liability insurance rose 62% between 2006-2015 and 2016-2025, even as claim counts held steady in several segments. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think lawsuit costs are making construction and infrastructure more expensive for you?

Average claim severity in Victor's U.S. architect and engineer professional liability portfolio rose 62% in nominal dollars from 2006-2015 to 2016-2025, while claim frequency in several segments stayed flat or declined. For construction-linked design firms, the cost of each claim is climbing even as claim counts hold steady.

Why it matters

Rising claim costs are being driven less by how often claims occur than by how expensive each one becomes to defend and settle. Construction input prices rising more than 45% between February 2020 and February 2026 also raise what it costs to fix errors once they reach the job site.

Victor's U.S. A&E average claim severity rose 62% in nominal terms and about 19% after inflation between the two decades studied, with 32% of 2016-2025 claims expense-only and generating nearly $220 million in defense and allocated loss adjustment expense. Construction input prices rose more than 45% from February 2020 to February 2026.

The players

Victor

A professional liability insurer whose U.S. and Canadian architect and engineer portfolios provide the claims data analyzed in this report.

Design-Build Institute of America

An industry organization that tracks and promotes design-build project delivery across U.S. construction.

The details

Claim costs rise through three channels: defense expenses, indemnity payments, and allocated loss adjustment expense. Settlement dynamics, contractual relationships, and joint and several exposure can push payments above a firm's proportional share of fault. Victor paid approximately $28.2 million in indemnity on closed U.S. claims from 2016-2025 where the insured's assessed liability was under 50%.

Timeline

  1. 2006-2015: baseline decade for Victor's claim severity comparison.

  2. 2016-2025: comparison decade showing the 62% nominal severity increase.

  3. February 2020 to February 2026: construction input prices rose more than 45%.

  4. 2017-2022: U.S. social inflation averaged 5.4% annually.

  5. 2028: Design-Build Institute of America projects design-build will reach 50% of U.S. construction spending.

Market Landscape

Social inflation averaged 5.4% annually in the U.S. from 2017 to 2022, against 3.7% economic inflation, and Victor's A&E severity trend tracks that pattern. Nuclear verdict concentration in California, Florida, New York, and Texas, all major construction states, adds to the pressure on design firms.

Design and engineering firms should expect professional liability premiums and retained defense costs to keep rising faster than claim counts. Firms and their insurance advisors should review contract indemnity clauses and joint liability terms with qualified counsel.

The takeaway

Claim severity, not frequency, is the variable to track in A&E risk budgeting over the coming year. Operators should ask their insurance broker for severity trends and defense cost breakdowns in their next renewal review.

Further reading

For context on how construction cost pressure shapes project risk, see the Construction section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Risk & Insurance.

Live Poll

Do you think lawsuit costs are making construction and infrastructure more expensive for you?