Patent Stipulation Dispute Tests IPR Outcomes
Companies that file or defend inter partes reviews may need to reassess how Sotera stipulations are written and enforced.
Updated on Nov. 5, 2026 in Business Strategy

Independent inventor Carrie Hafeman filed a petition with the USPTO asking the Director to vacate institution and Final Written Decisions in six related inter partes reviews, alleging Sotera Stipulation violations by Google and Microsoft. The filing follows a Federal Circuit denial of her rehearing petition one day earlier.
Why it matters
The case shows how a stipulation filed to limit the grounds of a patent challenge can become the basis for attacking the outcome of a proceeding years later. Businesses that rely on IPR challenges or defend patents against them should track how the Sotera stipulation is interpreted in this dispute.
The petition targets six related inter partes reviews, and three Hafeman patents covering remote device finder technology were invalidated across all claims by the PTAB and affirmed by the Federal Circuit in June 2026. LG's Sotera stipulation was filed on November 30, 2022, and the Board instituted review after declining discretionary denial based on it.
The players
U.S. Patent and Trademark Office
The federal agency that grants patents and administers inter partes review proceedings, which give businesses a route to challenge issued patents at the PTAB.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
The federal appeals court that reviews PTAB decisions and patent cases, and whose rulings set binding precedent on patent disputes affecting technology companies.
The details
Hafeman argues that LG violated its Sotera stipulation through backdoor methods, including relying on art from the IP in combination with other references. She raised the Sotera issue in all six IPR sur-replies and requested termination, but the Federal Circuit dismissed her argument that the IPRs should have been terminated on that basis. Her Extraordinary Director Review petition asks the Director to vacate both the institution decisions and the final written decisions in those reviews.
Timeline
November 30, 2022: LG filed the Sotera stipulation.
June 2026: The Federal Circuit affirmed PTAB invalidation of Hafeman's three patents.
October 2026: Hafeman filed a petition for rehearing with the Federal Circuit.
One day before November 5, 2026: The Federal Circuit denied the rehearing petition.
November 5, 2026: Hafeman filed the Extraordinary Director Review petition.
Market Landscape
Under the Sotera stipulation framework, petitioners agree to forgo certain invalidity grounds in exchange for institution of review, making the stipulation's scope central to PTAB outcomes. This petition asks whether a violation can be used to vacate proceedings that have already concluded.
Companies that file or defend inter partes reviews should review how their Sotera stipulations are drafted and how opposing parties may characterize compliance. Questions about how this affects specific patent strategy should go to qualified patent counsel.
The takeaway
A stipulation designed to narrow an IPR can become a litigation tool after a decision issues, so operators should ask counsel how any stipulation they sign will be read later. Watch whether the USPTO Director acts on the petition and whether Hafeman pursues Supreme Court review.
Further reading
For related coverage of competitive positioning and legal risk, see Business Strategy on We are Main Street.
Source note: This article includes information reported by IPWatchdog.com | Patents & Patent Law.




