Supreme Court to Weigh Pipeline Landowner Legal Fees

Pipeline operators and landowners in eminent domain cases face a pending ruling on who pays legal costs.

Updated on Nov. 6, 2026 in Utilities

Flat-color editorial illustration of a steel pipeline section in a shallow trench crossing open prairie, with a cleared right-of-way stretching toward the horizon.
WBI Energy Transmission faces a Supreme Court hearing on November 9, 2026, over whether it must pay North Dakota landowners' legal fees in eminent domain disputes. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should companies taking private land by eminent domain have to pay landowners' legal fees?

The US Supreme Court will hear a dispute over whether WBI Energy Transmission, a private natural gas pipeline company, must pay legal fees for North Dakota landowners whose property it seeks through eminent domain. The hearing is set for November 9, 2026, and the outcome could shape how pipeline developers compensate landowners nationwide.

Why it matters

The case turns on whether federal law or state law governs compensation when a company holding a federal certificate under the Natural Gas Act takes private land. The Eighth Circuit's March 2025 ruling that federal law controls overturned a $383,375.76 fee award, so the Supreme Court's answer will set the cost of contesting easement offers for landowners and the litigation exposure for pipeline operators.

A federal district court ordered WBI Energy Transmission to reimburse North Dakota landowners $383,375.76 in legal fees, a sum the Eighth Circuit later overturned in March 2025. WBI's initial offer for the easement was about half the property's market value, the figure that prompted the challenge.

The players

WBI Energy Transmission

A private natural gas pipeline company that holds a federal certificate under the Natural Gas Act and exercises eminent domain powers to acquire easements.

Institute for Justice

A public-interest law firm that represents the North Dakota ranchers in the eminent domain dispute.

US Supreme Court

The highest federal court, which will decide whether federal or state law governs landowner fee reimbursement in such cases.

The details

WBI Energy Transmission holds a federal certificate under the Natural Gas Act, which gives it eminent domain powers to acquire easements for pipeline construction. The dispute began in 2018, when the company told landowners, including rancher Leonard Hoffmann, that it planned to acquire an easement, and offered about half the market value. The parties later settled on the property value but left legal fees unresolved, and the Institute for Justice, representing the ranchers, sought reimbursement. The Eighth Circuit ruled that federal rather than state law governs such compensation, which removed the fee award.

Timeline

  1. 2018: WBI informed landowners of its planned easement acquisition.

  2. March 2025: The Eighth Circuit overturned the $383,375.76 fee award.

  3. November 9, 2026: The US Supreme Court hears the dispute in Washington, D.C.

Market Landscape

The case sits at the intersection of federal pipeline authority under the Natural Gas Act and state property-compensation traditions. The Eighth Circuit's federal-law ruling and the Supreme Court's pending review will define the cost structure for pipeline easement acquisitions across the country.

Pipeline developers should expect the cost of contested easements to depend on the Supreme Court's fee ruling, so the legal budget for acquisitions may shift. Landowners and the businesses that negotiate easements should track how federal compensation rules are applied in this case.

The takeaway

The Supreme Court's ruling on November 9, 2026 will set whether federal or state law governs easement fee reimbursement, so utilities and easement negotiators should plan their legal budgets around that outcome. Operators in the pipeline and energy sectors should review how the decision affects their acquisition costs once it issues.

What happens next

The US Supreme Court hears the dispute on November 9, 2026, and its ruling will determine whether landowners can recover legal fees from pipeline companies that seek their property.

Further reading

For broader context on how pipeline and energy infrastructure fits into the sector, see Utilities.

Live Poll

Should companies taking private land by eminent domain have to pay landowners' legal fees?