Bill Would End Rail Antitrust Exemptions
Shippers that depend on one railroad could gain new federal, state, and private rights to challenge anti-competitive rail deals.
Updated on Nov. 7, 2026 in Transportation

Live Poll
Should federal antitrust law apply to railroads and stop them from raising rates unchecked?
Sen. Herb Kohl introduced the Railroad Antitrust Enforcement Act of 2006 (S. 3612) on July 6, 2006, which would repeal antitrust exemptions for freight railroads. The bill was referred to the Senate Committee on the Judiciary, and it would affect shippers that depend on a single railroad.
Why it matters
Railroad mergers and collective ratemaking are currently exempt from antitrust review and handled by the Surface Transportation Board, which leaves shippers with few enforcement options. The bill's introduction followed a 93 percent rate jump for Dairyland Power Cooperative on January 1, 2006, after a three-year rail contract expired.
Dairyland Power Cooperative's rates rose 93 percent after its three-year rail contract expired, and it plans to spend about $75 million to ship $30 million worth of coal. The Association of American Railroads reports that coal shippers' rates fell 35 percent, while a GAO report found rail rates declined over the past 20 years.
The players
Dairyland Power Cooperative
A LaCrosse, Wis.-based electric utility cooperative whose rail shipping costs for coal rose sharply after its contract expired.
Sen. Herb Kohl
A Wisconsin Democrat who introduced the bill to repeal antitrust exemptions for freight railroads.
Sen. Russ Feingold
A Wisconsin Democrat who co-sponsored the Railroad Antitrust Enforcement Act of 2006.
Surface Transportation Board
The federal agency that currently reviews railroad mergers and acquisitions in place of antitrust enforcement.
Association of American Railroads
The trade association for U.S. freight railroads, which reported that coal shippers' rates dropped 35 percent.
The details
The bill would allow the federal government, state attorneys general, and private parties to sue to enjoin anti-competitive mergers and acquisitions, and it would restore review authority to the Justice Department's Antitrust Division and the Federal Trade Commission. Supporters argue that captive shippers, which rely on a single railroad, have faced monopolistic practices and price gouging. The bill was co-sponsored by Sen. Russ Feingold.
Timeline
January 1, 2006: Dairyland Power Cooperative's rates increased 93 percent.
May 2006: The Railroad Competition Act of 2006 (S. 2921) was introduced to the Senate.
July 6, 2006: Sen. Herb Kohl introduced the Railroad Antitrust Enforcement Act of 2006.
Market Landscape
The bill sits alongside the Railroad Competition Act of 2006 (S. 2921), introduced in May 2006, as Congress weighed how to address captive-shipper complaints. It reflects a long-running dispute over whether the Surface Transportation Board's merger review is sufficient for shippers with no alternative rail carrier.
Shippers that depend on a single railroad should track whether antitrust review of rail mergers and collective ratemaking changes. Operators with large freight costs should factor in the possibility of new litigation pathways and consult qualified counsel before making contract decisions.
The takeaway
Captive shippers facing a single rail carrier should monitor whether the bill advances in committee and how the Surface Transportation Board responds to it. Freight contract renewals are a practical point to review rate exposure, and qualified counsel should evaluate any litigation options.
Further reading
For broader context on how freight rail competition is regulated, explore Transportation coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by RailPrime.
Live Poll
Should federal antitrust law apply to railroads and stop them from raising rates unchecked?




