Board Talks on Regulatory Deals May Be Discoverable
Delaware public companies should expect stockholders to seek board communications about regulatory settlements through books-and-records demands.
Updated on Nov. 3, 2026 in Public Companies

Delaware's Court of Chancery partially granted a Facebook stockholder's demand for internal books and records tied to the company's 2019 Federal Trade Commission settlement, ruling on February 10, 2021. The court ordered production of certain board members' electronic communications about the settlement while declining to compel privileged documents.
Why it matters
Stockholders seeking to examine whether directors acted properly can use Section 220 demands to reach internal records, and this ruling shows where courts draw lines between board communications and privileged material. For operators of any public company, the decision underscores that board deliberations over regulatory settlements can become discoverable even when counsel is involved.
The ruling was issued February 10, 2021, roughly 19 months after Facebook's July 2019 FTC settlement over the Cambridge Analytica data release. The court granted the stockholder's demand in part and denied it in part, and the stub does not provide document counts or dollar figures for the settlement.
The players
Facebook, Inc.
Facebook operates the world's largest social media platform, generating revenue primarily from digital advertising, and was the subject of the 2019 FTC settlement.
Federal Trade Commission
The FTC is the federal agency that enforces consumer protection and antitrust laws against businesses, and it reached the 2019 settlement with Facebook over user data.
Delaware Court of Chancery
The Court of Chancery is Delaware's specialized equity court, which hears corporate governance disputes including stockholder books-and-records demands for many public companies incorporated in the state.
Cambridge Analytica
Cambridge Analytica was a political data analytics firm that received unauthorized access to Facebook user data, triggering the regulatory action.
The details
A Section 220 demand allows a stockholder with a proper purpose to inspect corporate books and records, and here the plaintiff argued that Facebook may have overpaid to protect its CEO from personal liability in the FTC matter. Facebook agreed to produce certain document categories but refused to hand over electronic communications among board members about the FTC negotiations and privileged materials. The court ordered production of the board members' communications on the settlement while declining to require production of the privileged documents.
Timeline
July 2019: Facebook settles with the Federal Trade Commission over the unauthorized release of user data to Cambridge Analytica.
February 10, 2021: Vice Chancellor Slights grants the stockholder demand in part and denies it in part.
Market Landscape
Delaware's Section 220 framework is the main route by which stockholders of Delaware-incorporated public companies obtain internal records before filing derivative suits. The Facebook ruling fits a pattern of Chancery courts weighing investor access to board materials against attorney-client privilege.
Public companies incorporated in Delaware should expect stockholders to use books-and-records demands to examine board conduct around regulatory settlements. Legal and governance teams should review how board communications on such matters are documented and preserved, and consult qualified counsel on privilege questions.
The takeaway
Board materials on regulatory negotiations can become discoverable under Section 220 even when privilege is asserted over other documents. Operators should confirm with counsel how their board communications are kept and what portion would be reachable in a stockholder inspection.
Further reading
For related coverage of how shareholder rights and disclosure play out across listed firms, explore Public Companies in our Delaware business section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Aoshearman.



