Court Lets Top-Customer RWI Claim Proceed
Acquirers buying with RWI coverage should note that top-customer representations can survive dismissal while ordinary-course claims may not.
Updated on Nov. 3, 2026 in Public Companies

A Delaware Superior Court judge sustained part of a breach of contract claim by Surteco North America against AIG Specialty Insurance Company over denied representations and warranties insurance (RWI) coverage tied to Surteco's acquisition of Omnova Solutions. Judge Kathleen Miller granted in part and denied in part AIG's motion to dismiss on July 6, 2026.
Why it matters
The ruling shows that RWI buyers may not recover for every alleged breach: claims tied to material adverse effect and ordinary-course representations were dismissed, while a top-customer representation claim survived. For deal teams, it underscores that policy language and the specific representations insured determine what coverage actually pays.
The court allowed one of three contested coverage theories to proceed while dismissing the other two. The top customer's termination came four months after a nine-month representation period, a timing gap that was central to the claim.
The players
AIG Specialty Insurance Company
A specialty insurer within the American International Group network that underwrites representations and warranties insurance policies for M&A transactions.
Surteco North America
The North American arm of a decorative surfaces manufacturer that acquired Omnova Solutions and bought RWI coverage for the deal.
Omnova Solutions
A specialty chemicals and surfaces company whose acquisition by Surteco was the transaction the RWI policy insured.
Judge Kathleen Miller
The Delaware Superior Court judge who ruled on AIG's motion to dismiss, the court where the commercial dispute is heard.
The details
The RWI policy was bought alongside Surteco's acquisition of Omnova Solutions and included a materiality scrape, which removed the materiality qualifier from the top-customer representation. The target had represented that it had not received written notice that a top customer intended to materially limit purchases. The court found the top-customer allegations sufficient despite their vagueness, but dismissed the material adverse effect and ordinary-course claims.
Timeline
Nine months before signing: the representation period for no written notice from a top customer began.
Four months after that period: the top customer terminated its contract with Omnova.
July 6, 2026: the Delaware Superior Court granted in part and denied in part AIG's motion to dismiss.
Market Landscape
Delaware is the default forum for many M&A disputes, so its Superior Court rulings on RWI claims carry weight across deal markets. This decision adds a data point on how judges treat vague top-customer representations versus more specific material adverse effect claims.
Deal teams buying RWI should check whether their policy includes a materiality scrape and how it applies to top-customer and ordinary-course representations before closing. Coverage for vague or ordinary-course claims may be harder to recover than buyers expect, so review those terms with qualified counsel.
The takeaway
Before signing an RWI-backed deal, review whether the policy's materiality scrape covers the representations that matter most to your business, especially top-customer and ordinary-course claims. Track customer contract renewal and termination timing against representation periods, and have qualified counsel review any policy language before you rely on it.
Further reading
For more on how acquisition disputes like this one play out in corporate filings and market reporting, see Public Companies.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Aoshearman.



