Judge Affirms $383 Million Verdict in Utility Lawsuit

Contractor liability ruling serves as a warning for operators managing high-stakes industrial infrastructure overhauls.

Updated on Oct. 21, 2026 in Utilities

Isometric editorial illustration of a heavy industrial turbine ring, representing the infrastructure failure at the center of a major court verdict.
A U.S. District Court judge affirmed a $383 million verdict against Toshiba America Energy following breach of warranty litigation in Michigan. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should utility ratepayers be responsible for costs following a contractor's breach of warranty?

A U.S. District Court judge has affirmed a $383 million jury verdict against Toshiba America Energy regarding a breach of warranty case. The ruling follows years of litigation over equipment failures at Michigan’s Ludington Pumped Storage facility.

Why it matters

The decision highlights the significant financial exposure utility operators face when large-scale infrastructure overhauls fail to meet design and construction standards. For operators, the case underscores the importance of rigorous warranty enforcement in high-value, multi-year industrial contracts.

The jury award stands at $383 million, a fraction of the $780 million in damages sought by the utilities. Total repair costs for the project, which involved an original $560 million contract, exceeded $508 million.

The players

Toshiba America Energy

A subsidiary of a major multinational conglomerate specializing in energy infrastructure, power generation equipment, and industrial systems.

F. Kay Behm

A U.S. District Judge overseeing the breach of warranty litigation.

Voith

A global technology company that provides engineering, machinery, and services for the power, oil and gas, and transport sectors.

The details

The dispute centers on allegations that Toshiba used unsuitable metal for discharge ring extensions and improperly removed stainless-steel overlays during a 2015 overhaul. These defects restricted the pump-turbine operations to just 50 hours per year, necessitating extensive repairs by Voith to restore functionality to the 1,875-MW facility.

Timeline

  1. 2010: Utilities contracted Toshiba for the hydro plant overhaul.

  2. 2015: Upgrade work began at the facility.

  3. 2019: Utilities discovered alleged equipment defects.

  4. 2023: MPSC permitted tracking of repair costs.

  5. December 2025: Jury returned the original verdict.

Market Landscape

This judgment concludes a long-running legal challenge that follows the regulatory framework established by the 2023 MPSC repair cost tracking authorization. The ruling establishes a final liability figure that may influence how utilities seek to recover remaining repair expenses from state ratepayers.

Operators managing complex infrastructure should ensure that contract warranties clearly define technical failure thresholds to facilitate easier recovery of repair costs. Watch for future regulatory filings to see if the utility seeks to pass the remaining $508 million in repair costs to the rate base.

The takeaway

This case demonstrates that warranty litigation can take nearly a decade to resolve, leaving operators to shoulder significant repair costs in the interim. Managers should prioritize clear, enforceable warranty language to mitigate the risks associated with multi-year mechanical overhauls.

Further reading

For more on the regulatory environment governing infrastructure projects, visit our Utilities section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Engineering News-Record (ENR) magazine.

Live Poll

Should utility ratepayers be responsible for costs following a contractor's breach of warranty?