Judge Upholds $345 Million Greenpeace Judgment Pending Appeal
Pipeline operators and their contractors face a judgment that stays in place while Greenpeace appeals to the state supreme court.
Updated on Nov. 2, 2026 in Industry

Live Poll
Do you think corporations should be able to sue activist groups for protest damages?
A North Dakota judge denied Greenpeace's request for a new trial in Energy Transfer's Dakota Access Pipeline lawsuit on November 2, 2025, leaving a $345 million judgment in place. Greenpeace says it will appeal to the North Dakota Supreme Court, a step that keeps the case open for North Dakota businesses that rely on pipeline infrastructure and the legal risk that comes with protest-related litigation.
Why it matters
Judge James Gion said every juror pledged under oath to decide impartially and warned that a second trial in Fargo could cause years of delay for other cases. The ruling signals that the court views the verdict as stable, pushing the dispute toward appellate review rather than a retrial.
The judgment stands at $345 million, down from the roughly $667 million the Morton County jury originally directed Greenpeace to pay Energy Transfer. The three-week trial featured dozens of witnesses before Judge Gion's court.
The players
Greenpeace
An international environmental advocacy organization that campaigns against fossil fuel infrastructure and runs a global network of national and regional affiliates.
Energy Transfer
A large U.S. midstream energy company that operates crude oil and natural gas pipelines, including the Dakota Access Pipeline.
James Gion
A North Dakota district judge who presided over the Morton County trial and ruled on Greenpeace's post-trial motions.
North Dakota Supreme Court
The state's highest court, which will hear Greenpeace's appeal of the judgment and has previously ruled in the related Greenpeace International matter.
The details
Greenpeace argued the jury pool was biased in Energy Transfer's favor and proposed Cass County as a venue for a new trial. Gion rejected the request, noting that jurors affirmed their impartiality under oath and that a retrial would prolong litigation. He wrote that Greenpeace's remaining legal-error claims belong in the appeals process, and he ordered Greenpeace International to withdraw certain claims in its separate Netherlands lawsuit.
Timeline
Anti-pipeline protests against the Dakota Access Pipeline took place in North Dakota in 2016 and 2017.
A Morton County jury returned its verdict in early 2025, directing Greenpeace to pay about $667 million.
Judge Gion denied Greenpeace's motion for a new trial on November 2, 2025.
Market Landscape
The case follows the 2016-2017 Dakota Access Pipeline protests, which led to a series of lawsuits over protest conduct and pipeline opposition. It shows how pipeline operators have pursued damages against advocacy groups, a pattern that shapes how energy companies and their contractors weigh litigation against activism.
Operators in oil and gas midstream and related contracting should treat protest-related litigation as a continuing cost and legal exposure in North Dakota. Companies working near pipeline projects should review contractor and security arrangements with qualified counsel, since appeals may extend the case for years.
The takeaway
Operators should expect appellate review of this judgment to extend the dispute for an uncertain period and should track the North Dakota Supreme Court docket for any ruling. Businesses with exposure to pipeline opposition should consult qualified counsel on how verdicts like this one affect contract, insurance, and risk-allocation terms.
What happens next
Greenpeace will file its appeal with the North Dakota Supreme Court; the filing date was not specified in the source.
Further reading
For related coverage, see Oil and Gas reporting on pipeline operations and regulation in North Dakota.
Source note: This article includes information reported by INFORUM.
Live Poll
Do you think corporations should be able to sue activist groups for protest damages?





