We Are Main Street

Underwriting Discipline Is Vital for Legacy Insurers

Insurers facing soft market conditions should refine reserving and litigation strategies to manage capital and earnings.

Updated on Oct. 21, 2026 in Business

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a balance scale with weights and a chest, representing insurance risk, using economist-style geometric composition.
RiverStone International Group's focus on underwriting discipline provides a strategic shield against earnings volatility in softening legacy insurance markets. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust that your insurance provider will honor your policy's long-term claims?

RiverStone International Group CEO Paul Brockman detailed the importance of underwriting discipline in the legacy insurance sector during a recent conference in New Jersey. As market conditions soften, operators are increasingly leveraging legacy transactions to manage capital and reduce earnings volatility.

Why it matters

Softening market conditions often make organic growth difficult for insurers, prompting a strategic shift toward M&A and legacy transaction management. Firms must maintain rigorous discipline in reserves and litigation strategy to protect balance sheets against volatility during these industry cycles.

Group CEO Paul Brockman brings 33 years of insurance and reinsurance experience to the management of RiverStone International's global platforms. The firm currently executes transactions across the UK, Lloyd's, Europe, Bermuda, the US, and Australia.

The players

Paul Brockman

Group CEO of RiverStone International with over 33 years of experience in the insurance and reinsurance sectors.

RiverStone International

A global insurance services firm operating platforms in the UK, Lloyd's, Europe, Bermuda, the US, and Australia.

The details

RiverStone International maintains operational discipline by rigorously challenging claims assumptions, current reserving practices, and market perceptions. By evaluating litigation risks and legal interpretations, the company seeks to stabilize earnings while using legacy deals to provide capital relief for insurers. This strategy allows the firm to navigate softening market conditions by identifying and acquiring specific lines of business that require specialized management.

Timeline

  1. January 2026: Paul Brockman joined RiverStone International as Group CEO.

  2. October 19, 2026: Paul Brockman addressed the AIRROC conference in New Jersey.

Market Landscape

Brockman's strategy aligns with the industry's documented shift toward using legacy transactions as a primary lever for capital relief and earnings stability. This approach reflects a broader trend of insurers offloading blocks of business to specialized platforms to counter the challenges of achieving organic growth in softening markets.

Operators in the insurance sector should re-evaluate their current earnings volatility and capital requirements to determine if legacy transactions offer a viable relief strategy. Management teams must concurrently audit their claims assumptions and litigation reserves to ensure they align with disciplined market standards.

The takeaway

Legacy transactions represent a strategic defensive move for insurers facing stagnant organic growth. Monitor your firm's earnings volatility metrics and litigation reserves to identify which specific blocks of business might be candidates for capital relief maneuvers in the coming months.

Further reading

For additional context on navigating sector-specific volatility, visit Business Strategy.

Source note: This article includes information reported by ReinsuranceNe.

Live Poll

Do you trust that your insurance provider will honor your policy's long-term claims?