Texas Highway Builders Lose Insurance Coverage Ruling
Contractors now face greater liability risk as courts narrow the scope of duty to defend for post-completion highway incidents.
Updated on Oct. 29, 2026 in Industry

Live Poll
Do you trust that insurance companies generally honor their coverage obligations during major legal disputes?
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled that Liberty Mutual is not obligated to defend highway contractors in lawsuits linked to a 2021 vehicle pileup. The decision hinges on the court determination that the litigation alleged operational failures rather than construction defects.
Why it matters
For infrastructure firms, this ruling clarifies that insurance coverage for historical projects may not extend to operational incidents if the complaints do not directly challenge the original construction work. It underscores the critical need for contractors to ensure their liability policies precisely define the scope of covered activities.
A Dallas County jury previously awarded $44.1 million against other defendants, while this ruling relieves the builders of defense obligations for the 130-car pileup that resulted in six deaths and 65 injuries. The court cited a poorly drafted policy as a factor in the dispute.
The players
Liberty Mutual
A global provider of property and casualty insurance products that manages commercial liability coverage for construction firms.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
The federal appellate body with jurisdiction over Texas that interprets insurance contract law in liability disputes.
The details
Liberty Mutual initially provided a defense for the builders under a reservation of rights but later successfully argued against coverage in federal court. The judges concluded that the underlying lawsuits centered on maintenance and operational failures occurring after the 2013-2018 construction period. Consequently, because the claims did not allege that the construction work itself caused the bodily injuries, the policy did not trigger a duty to defend the firms.
Timeline
Construction work on the I-35 West section took place from 2013 to 2018.
The 130-car pileup occurred on I-35 West in Fort Worth on February 11, 2021.
A Dallas County jury awarded a $44.1 million verdict in December 2025.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled in favor of Liberty Mutual on October 29, 2026.
Market Landscape
This decision marks a departure from expectations of broad defense coverage for long-completed infrastructure projects. It follows the pattern set by the 2021 I-35 West vehicle pileup in Fort Worth, where multiple parties now face distinct legal and financial consequences.
Operators should review their historical project insurance policies to verify how coverage definitions handle operational versus construction-specific claims. Consult with legal counsel to confirm whether your current liability language sufficiently protects against third-party claims post-completion.
The takeaway
The court ruling highlights that even clunky or poorly drafted insurance policies serve as the final authority in liability disputes. Review existing project documents now to confirm whether your firm has defined the specific activities that trigger a duty to defend versus those that fall into operational liability gaps.
Further reading
For broader insights on industry standards, browse the Texas Construction archive.
Live Poll
Do you trust that insurance companies generally honor their coverage obligations during major legal disputes?




