Casey's Takeover Pulls Local Products From Shelves
Local food vendors selling through Pak-A-Sak stores must now seek shelf space with the new owner, Casey's.
Updated on Nov. 7, 2026 in Openings & Closings
Live Poll
Do you think your area is losing its local businesses?
Pak-A-Sak convenience stores in Amarillo were sold to Casey's, and the local products they carried have been pulled from those locations. The Cake Company fried pies are no longer sold at Pak-A-Sak, and Grandma's Burritos stopped being available there after October 30.
Why it matters
Local vendors that relied on convenience-store shelf space lose a sales channel when a store changes hands, and the replacement chain's product decisions govern what stays on the shelf. The stores are transitioning to Casey's following the sale, which is the stated reason for the removals.
The Cake Company pies, sold at Pak-A-Sak beginning April 2026, are now carried at 10 listed Toot'n Totum locations. The number of Pak-A-Sak stores affected by the sale was not stated in the reporting.
The players
Casey's
Casey's is a major U.S. convenience store chain that acquired the Pak-A-Sak locations.
The Cake Company
The Cake Company is a local Canyon bakery producing fried pies sold through local retail partners.
Toot'n Totum
Toot'n Totum is a regional convenience store chain now carrying The Cake Company fried pies at 10 locations.
The details
Pak-A-Sak locations stopped carrying The Cake Company pies as they transitioned to Casey's, according to a cashier who told a customer the change was due to the Casey's transition. Grandma's Burritos are no longer available at Pak-A-Sak after October 30, while remaining available at two listed locations. The Cake Company has moved its fried pies to Toot'n Totum, and customers can also buy them directly at The Cake Company in Canyon.
Timeline
August 2026: Readers were informed that Pak-A-Sak stores were sold to Casey's.
April 2026: The Cake Company began selling fried pies at Pak-A-Sak.
October 30, 2026: Grandma's Burritos stopped being available at Pak-A-Sak.
November 6, 2026: A Pak-A-Sak visit found fried pies unavailable.
Market Landscape
The Pak-A-Sak sale to Casey's, reported in August 2026, moved these stores under a larger chain's product decisions. Local food producers that had gained shelf space through the prior owner now depend on whether the new owner allows local vendors.
Local food vendors selling through convenience stores should confirm whether their products remain stocked after any change in store ownership. Vendors should contact the new owner's purchasing contacts directly rather than assuming shelf space will carry over.
The takeaway
Operators whose products sit on convenience-store shelves should treat an ownership change as a reset of their vendor relationship. Track whether Casey's responds to requests for local vendor participation before planning around any return of these products.
Further reading
For more on store sales and closures in the area, see Openings & Closings in Amarillo.
Source note: This article includes information reported by 96.9 KISS FM.
Live Poll
Do you think your area is losing its local businesses?
