Court Weighs Fate of Horse Heaven Hills Windfarm
Energy developers in Washington face an unresolved state Supreme Court review that could uphold, remand, or halt the windfarm approval.
Updated on Nov. 3, 2026 in Utilities

Live Poll
Should large windfarms be built despite local opposition over land and wildlife?
The Washington State Supreme Court has not yet ruled on a lawsuit challenging the state's approval of the Horse Heaven Hills windfarm, a project that could span 25 miles or more from Finley. For utilities and energy developers in Washington, the outcome will determine whether a large-scale wind project can proceed under its current approval.
Why it matters
Opposition from local citizens, Benton County, and the Yakama Tribal Nation has run since 2021, with hundreds of pages of testimony submitted, leaving the approval vulnerable to legal challenge. Because the court can uphold, remand, or invalidate the approval, developers and utilities face a range of outcomes that affect project timelines and planning.
The proposed project would stretch 25 miles or more from Finley and include as many as 116 turbines in the latest Scout Energy proposal, with local opposition active since 2021. The number of turbines and project scope are tied to the latest proposal rather than a finalized configuration, and the court has not ruled on the approval covering them.
The players
Scout Energy
Colorado-based energy developer that has submitted the latest proposal for the Horse Heaven Hills windfarm, which could include as many as 116 turbines.
TC Cares
Local opposition group that has led efforts against the windfarm alongside Benton County and the Yakama Nation, and that issued the October 30 lawsuit status update.
Benton County
Washington county government that has opposed the windfarm project alongside local citizens and the Yakama Tribal Nation.
Yakama Tribal Nation
Tribal government that has opposed the Horse Heaven Hills windfarm since 2021, citing habitat and other concerns.
Washington State Supreme Court
State's highest court, which will decide whether to uphold, remand, or reverse the state's approval of the windfarm.
The details
The lawsuit challenges the state's approval of the farm, and the state Supreme Court can respond by upholding the approval, remanding it so the state must revise parts before deciding again, or reversing it. If the approval is affirmed, construction could proceed as currently planned; if the case is remanded, the state must revise portions of the approval; if it is invalidated, the project cannot advance unless the state restarts the process. Opposition centers on destruction of native plant, bird, and animal habitat and on firefighting and other long-term concerns.
Timeline
2021: Opposition to the Horse Heaven Hills windfarm project began.
October 30: TC Cares sent its latest update saying the court decision could take months.
November 3, 2026: Article published; the court had still not ruled.
Market Landscape
The Horse Heaven Hills project sits in a pending judicial review of a state-issued approval, where the Washington State Supreme Court's options range from full affirmance to remand or reversal. The dispute mirrors the local-government and tribal opposition that has shaped the approval history of this project since 2021.
Energy developers and utilities with projects in pending or contested approvals should factor in the possibility of a remand or invalidation that would require a restarted state process. Qualified counsel can help assess how a Supreme Court ruling in either direction would affect contract timing and permitting exposure.
The takeaway
Watch for the Washington State Supreme Court's ruling on the Horse Heaven Hills approval, which will determine whether construction proceeds, is sent back for revision, or is halted. Operators with exposure to Washington wind development should review project contingencies with qualified counsel while the court's timing remains unknown.
Further reading
For broader context on how the state's power sector is regulated, explore Utilities coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by NEWStalk 870.
Live Poll
Should large windfarms be built despite local opposition over land and wildlife?





