NYC Bans Surveillance Pricing Based on Browsing Data

Businesses selling to New York City customers must stop using browsing data to set different prices for the same product.

Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Economics

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of identical stacked shipping cartons in deep red and cream, one carton offset, conveying uniform goods with varying prices.
New York City Council passed a 44-5 bill banning surveillance pricing, barring businesses from using browsing data to charge customers different prices for the same product. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you think companies should be banned from charging you different prices based on your data?

The New York City Council passed a bill 44-5 banning surveillance pricing, the practice of using browsing data to charge customers different prices for the same product. Companies that fail to comply face a $1,000 fine, and the law takes effect for businesses that set prices in the city.

Why it matters

Speaker Julie Menin said companies set different prices for the same product by drawing on consumers' demographics, browsing history, shopping habits, and social media activity. The measure responds to scrutiny of ride-hailing, grocery, retail, and airline firms and puts a concrete cost on pricing practices that were previously unregulated locally.

The City Council approved the measure by a 44-5 vote, with a $1,000 fine for businesses that fail to comply. The law applies to companies setting prices for customers in New York City.

The players

New York City Council

The city's legislative body, which writes and passes local laws governing businesses operating within the five boroughs.

Uber

A ride-hailing and delivery platform whose business relies on algorithmic pricing across its mobility and food services.

Lyft

A ride-hailing company competing with Uber in U.S. urban mobility markets, using dynamic pricing to match riders and drivers.

Target

A large U.S. general merchandise retailer operating physical stores and e-commerce, one of the largest retail employers in the country.

Instacart

A grocery delivery and pickup platform connecting shoppers with retailers, whose pricing practices have drawn scrutiny from regulators and consumer advocates.

The details

The law prohibits companies from using browsing data to charge customers different prices for the same product. It permits transparent loyalty programs and certain discounts, so firms can still reward customers openly without relying on hidden individualized pricing. Uber, Lyft, Target, Instacart and airlines have faced scrutiny over alleged surveillance pricing, and many of those companies have denied using the practice.

Timeline

  1. November 12, 2026: City Council passed the surveillance pricing ban 44-5.

  2. November 13, 2026: Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced the ban in a post on X.

Market Landscape

The measure extends local regulation from general price-setting into individualized pricing built on personal data, a category most jurisdictions have not addressed directly. It places New York among the first cities to tie a fine to the use of browsing data in price setting.

Businesses that set prices for New York City customers should review whether their pricing relies on browsing data or personal profiles, since the law prohibits that practice. Loyalty programs and discounts that are transparent remain permitted, so operators should document how each offer is structured. Companies should consult qualified counsel to assess compliance before the law takes effect.

The takeaway

Operators should treat individualized pricing built on personal data as a regulated practice in New York City, and calendar the compliance review with counsel. Monitoring whether other cities adopt similar measures will signal how far this rule spreads.

Further reading

For broader context on how pricing rules are shaping costs, see Inflation coverage in New York City.

Live Poll

Do you think companies should be banned from charging you different prices based on your data?