Unpaid Rent Costs Soho Hotel Its Operator

Hotel owners with sale-leaseback arrangements should review rent covenants and default terms before operating under a lease-back.

Updated on Nov. 4, 2026 in Hospitality

Photograph of a tall cast-iron loft building facade in SoHo under overcast daylight, with rows of tall multi-pane windows.
RFR Holding surrendered the 211-key 11 Howard hotel in Soho to landlord Commerz Real after a judge ordered possession over more than $18 million in unpaid rent. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

RFR Holding has surrendered the 211-key luxury hotel at 11 Howard in Soho to its landlord, Commerz Real, after a judge ordered possession. Ennismore, backed by Accor, has taken over as operator, ending a dispute over unpaid rent that Commerz says exceeds $18 million.

Why it matters

The dispute turns on a sale-leaseback arrangement in which RFR stopped paying rent in March 2023 while Commerz alleged the property was shopped to potential buyers, a claim RFR disputes in its own complaint. For hospitality operators in New York City, the case shows how quickly a lease-back structure can shift control of a hotel to a landlord and a new operator when rent payments lapse.

The 211-key hotel changed hands in a dispute where Commerz claims more than $18 million in back rent, taxes, insurance and other costs. The building was bought by RFR for $89.7 million in 2014 and later sold to Commerz for $170 million.

The players

RFR Holding

A New York real estate firm that bought, developed and operated the 11 Howard hotel before losing possession under the lease dispute.

Commerz Real

The real estate investment arm of Commerzbank that owns the 11 Howard property and pursued eviction over unpaid rent.

Ennismore

A hospitality company backed by Accor that operates boutique and lifestyle hotel brands and has taken over operation of the hotel.

Accor

A global hotel group that operates a broad portfolio of brands and backs Ennismore, the new operator at 11 Howard.

The details

RFR and Commerz entered a sale-leaseback structure in which Commerz bought the property and RFR leased it back, with an initial 10-year term and an option to extend. Commerz says RFR owed $2.8 million in real estate taxes it had guaranteed, and it petitioned for eviction. RFR countered with a complaint that Commerz violated the lease by shopping the property to potential buyers.

Timeline

  1. 2014: RFR buys the former Holiday Inn for $89.7 million.

  2. 2016: The upscale 11 Howard hotel opens.

  3. March 2023: RFR allegedly stops paying rent on the property.

  4. Last spring: A possession trial is held in New York City Civil Court.

  5. This week, November 2026: RFR hands the hotel back to Commerz Real.

Market Landscape

The dispute fits a broader pattern in which sale-leaseback hotel structures leave operators exposed when rent stops and the landlord controls possession. The handover to Ennismore, which is backed by Accor, places a major hotel group's operating platform at a Soho property that had been run under a separate owner-operator arrangement.

Hotel owners and operators with sale-leaseback arrangements should review rent payment terms, guarantee obligations and buyer-marketing restrictions with qualified counsel. Operators taking over distressed properties should expect a transition in staffing and brand standards.

The takeaway

Sale-leaseback structures can transfer possession quickly once rent lapses, so hospitality operators should track rent covenants and guarantee exposure closely. Operators evaluating a lease-back should have counsel review default and buyer-marketing provisions before signing.

Further reading

For more on how lease and ownership disputes are reshaping the sector, see our Hospitality coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Real Deal New York.